Scissor Labels

This article introduces the concept of “scissor labels”—terms that emerge when a new, organic creative movement gains traction but resists easy definition (e.g., Hyperpop). These labels become contested as debates over their meaning erupt, often masking deeper stakes like commercialization, cultural ownership, or preserving artistic authenticity. The author argues such debates are distractions from the core value of the movement itself. Using Hyperpop pioneer SOPHIE as a case study, the piece highlights how her innovative work transcended labels while sparking definitional arguments. The author critiques getting “stuck” in binary categorizations (“Is this Hyperpop?”) or land grabs for cultural capital, which risks stifling creativity and reducing movements to fads. To navigate scissor labels productively, two strategies are proposed: 1. Identify the real stakes: Move beyond semantic debates to address underlying concerns (e.g., community values vs commercialization). 2. Replace binaries with spectra or subcategories: Acknowledge complexity by framing categories as evolving and multifaceted rather than rigid definitions. However, the article emphasizes that most debates aren’t worth engaging in—they divert attention from what truly matters: pushing ideas forward. The key is to prioritize future innovation over present-day categorization. SOPHIE’s legacy exemplifies this mindset—her focus was on reinvention, not labels, keeping Hyperpop dynamic. The author urges readers to recognize scissor labels as markers of exciting, emergent ideas but to avoid anchoring themselves in debates about them. Instead, they should channel energy into creating and evolving these movements organically. The essay closes by celebrating SOPHIE’s impact and advocating for a future-oriented approach to art, tech, and culture. Final note: Written by a product designer interested in spatial software and crypto, the piece blends critique of cultural dynamics with practical advice on fostering creativity over clout-driven discourse.